Many non-profit plan sponsors have never experienced a true advisory relationship. What they have experienced is a product sale followed by minimal ongoing contact. Someone came in, presented a retirement plan option, helped with the initial setup, and then largely disappeared. Annual statements arrive. The plan continues to operate. And the plan sponsor, busy with the hundred other things on their plate, assumes that if nothing is obviously broken, everything must be fine.
This experience is more common than it should be, and it leaves a significant portion of the non-profit retirement plan market without the ongoing guidance and oversight that their plans, their participants, and their fiduciary obligations actually require. For advisors who do this work differently, there is both a real opportunity and a responsibility to help plan sponsors understand what a genuine advisory relationship looks like.
The Core Distinction
The most fundamental difference between an advisory relationship and a transactional one is where the engagement ends. A transaction ends at the sale. An advisory relationship is designed to continue and deepen over time.
An advisor who is genuinely serving a non-profit plan sponsor shows up for the annual plan review. They help the committee prepare for and document investment review meetings. They benchmark plan fees periodically against market comparables. They stay current on regulatory changes and communicate the ones that matter to the plan sponsor. They are available when human resources staff have questions, when employees are confused about their options, and when something in the plan needs attention.
None of this is exotic. It is simply what ongoing service looks like when someone is actually doing the job. But for plan sponsors who have only experienced the transactional version, it can feel like a meaningful step up.
What Ongoing Service Should Include
Different plans and different plan sponsors have different needs, but a reasonable baseline for ongoing advisory service in the non-profit retirement space typically includes regular plan review meetings with documented minutes, periodic fee benchmarking against comparable plans, investment lineup review at least annually, communication support for plan participants, responsiveness to compliance questions and regulatory updates, and assistance navigating vendor relationships and service issues.
Some of these services are more advisor-intensive than others, and the specific mix should be discussed and agreed upon at the outset of the relationship. What matters is that the plan sponsor understands what they are receiving and that the advisor is actually delivering it.
Why It Matters for Fiduciary Purposes
Fiduciary responsibility does not end when a plan is set up. It is ongoing, and it requires ongoing attention. Plan sponsors who have no advisory relationship, or who have a nominal one in which the advisor does very little, are shouldering that fiduciary burden largely alone. When something goes wrong, the absence of a documented advisory process becomes very visible.
Plan sponsors who work with an engaged advisor, by contrast, have a partner in their fiduciary process. They have documentation that decisions were reviewed, that fees were benchmarked, that the investment lineup was evaluated. That documentation does not eliminate risk, but it demonstrates the kind of prudent process that fiduciary standards are designed to encourage.
How to Have the Conversation
For advisors approaching a plan sponsor who has only experienced the transactional version of this relationship, the conversation does not need to be critical of whoever came before. It simply needs to paint a clear picture of what ongoing support looks like and why it matters.
Ask the plan sponsor what kind of contact they currently have with their advisor. Ask when the last plan review meeting was held and whether there are minutes. Ask whether fees have been benchmarked recently. These questions, asked without judgment, quickly clarify the current state of affairs and create a natural opening for a different kind of conversation.
Plan sponsors who have been underserved are often relieved to discover that more support is available. The ones who have simply never thought about the question are often surprised that ongoing service is a reasonable expectation. Either way, the conversation opens a door.
Leave a Reply